I'm not too sure why others didn't like this, maybe they just wanted Will, maybe they've never experienced grief or maybe they just didn't read past chapter 3. I felt it perfectly captured and reflected Lou going through grief and trying to land back on her feet again after Will and what it takes to get there. It was a delightful read with so many twists and turns, I really didn't want to stop reading it. I thoroughly enjoyed it and couldn't wait until I had moments free just to read a page or two here and there. Excited to read the third one!!!